On The Edge About Toast

I'm kind of on the edge about toast. If I put the toaster on setting 1 then it is too light the if I put it on setting 2 then it is stilll too light but if I put it on setting 3 then it is too dark. I got a little advice from a friend to put the toaster on setting 2 1/2 and i tried it and it was too dark still. so I really don't know what to do about the toast maybe it is the bread or maybe the toaster I don't know about the toast so that is why i'm kind of on the edeg about toast.I know that this sounds like a lot of complayning about toast but this is a bad matter.

Picture from badcop69 on deviantART